Validation of Mortality Data Sources Compared to the National Death Index in the Healthcare Integrated Research Database

Aziza Jamal-Allial,1 Todd Sponholtz,1 Shiva K Vojjala,2 Mark Paullin,2 Anahit Papazian,1 Biruk Eshete,2 Seyed Hamidreza Mahmoudpour,3 Patrice Verpillat,3 Daniel C Beachler2 1Safety & Epidemiology, Carelon Research, Newton, MA, USA; 2Safety & Epidemiology, Carelon Research, Wilmington, DE, US...

Full description

Saved in:
Bibliographic Details
Main Authors: Jamal-Allial A, Sponholtz T, Vojjala SK, Paullin M, Papazian A, Eshete B, Mahmoudpour SH, Verpillat P, Beachler DC
Format: Article
Language:English
Published: Dove Medical Press 2025-02-01
Series:Pragmatic and Observational Research
Subjects:
Online Access:https://www.dovepress.com/validation-of-mortality-data-sources-compared-to-the-national-death-in-peer-reviewed-fulltext-article-POR
Tags: Add Tag
No Tags, Be the first to tag this record!
_version_ 1823861421133266944
author Jamal-Allial A
Sponholtz T
Vojjala SK
Paullin M
Papazian A
Eshete B
Mahmoudpour SH
Verpillat P
Beachler DC
author_facet Jamal-Allial A
Sponholtz T
Vojjala SK
Paullin M
Papazian A
Eshete B
Mahmoudpour SH
Verpillat P
Beachler DC
author_sort Jamal-Allial A
collection DOAJ
description Aziza Jamal-Allial,1 Todd Sponholtz,1 Shiva K Vojjala,2 Mark Paullin,2 Anahit Papazian,1 Biruk Eshete,2 Seyed Hamidreza Mahmoudpour,3 Patrice Verpillat,3 Daniel C Beachler2 1Safety & Epidemiology, Carelon Research, Newton, MA, USA; 2Safety & Epidemiology, Carelon Research, Wilmington, DE, USA; 3Merck Healthcare KGaA, Darmstadt, GermanyCorrespondence: Daniel C Beachler, Carelon Research, 123 Justison Street, Suite 200, Wilmington, DE, 19801, USA, Email [email protected]: The National Death Index (NDI) is the gold standard for mortality data in the United States (US) but has a time lag and can be operationally intensive. This validation study assesses the accuracy of various mortality data sources with the NDI.Methods: This validation study is a secondary analysis of an advanced cancer cohort in the US between January 2010 and December 2018, with an established NDI linkage. Mortality data sources, inpatient discharge, disenrollment, death master file (DMF), Center for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS), Utilization management data (U.M.), and online obituary data were compared to NDI.Results: Among 40,692 patients, 25,761 (63.3%) had a death date using NDI; the composite algorithm had a sensitivity of 88.9% (95% CI = 88.5%, 89.3%), specificity was 89.1% (95% CI = 88.6%, 89.6%). At the same time, positive predictive value (PPV) was 93.4% (95% CI = 93.1%, 93.7%), negative predictive value (NPV) was 82.3% (95% CI = 81.7%, 82.9%), and when comparing each individual source, each had a high PPV but limited sensitivity.Conclusion: The composite algorithm was demonstrated to be a sensitive and precise measure of mortality, while individual database sources were accurate but had limited sensitivity.Plain Language Summary: What is known on this topic:The National Death Index (NDI) is the gold standard for ascertaining death in the US, with several limitations, such as time lag and population restrictions.What this study adds:A composite mortality algorithm of several sources of death was shown to be a sensitive and precise in death ascertainment compared to the NDI.Individual mortality sources, such as the Social Security Death Master File and online obituaries, had limited sensitivity on their own compared to the NDI.Keywords: mortality, validation, National Death Index, real word evidence, obituary, claims
format Article
id doaj-art-9d97298371e54b53903d079c135c08cf
institution Kabale University
issn 1179-7266
language English
publishDate 2025-02-01
publisher Dove Medical Press
record_format Article
series Pragmatic and Observational Research
spelling doaj-art-9d97298371e54b53903d079c135c08cf2025-02-09T16:10:20ZengDove Medical PressPragmatic and Observational Research1179-72662025-02-01Volume 16192599981Validation of Mortality Data Sources Compared to the National Death Index in the Healthcare Integrated Research DatabaseJamal-Allial ASponholtz TVojjala SKPaullin MPapazian AEshete BMahmoudpour SHVerpillat PBeachler DCAziza Jamal-Allial,1 Todd Sponholtz,1 Shiva K Vojjala,2 Mark Paullin,2 Anahit Papazian,1 Biruk Eshete,2 Seyed Hamidreza Mahmoudpour,3 Patrice Verpillat,3 Daniel C Beachler2 1Safety & Epidemiology, Carelon Research, Newton, MA, USA; 2Safety & Epidemiology, Carelon Research, Wilmington, DE, USA; 3Merck Healthcare KGaA, Darmstadt, GermanyCorrespondence: Daniel C Beachler, Carelon Research, 123 Justison Street, Suite 200, Wilmington, DE, 19801, USA, Email [email protected]: The National Death Index (NDI) is the gold standard for mortality data in the United States (US) but has a time lag and can be operationally intensive. This validation study assesses the accuracy of various mortality data sources with the NDI.Methods: This validation study is a secondary analysis of an advanced cancer cohort in the US between January 2010 and December 2018, with an established NDI linkage. Mortality data sources, inpatient discharge, disenrollment, death master file (DMF), Center for Medicare and Medicaid Services (CMS), Utilization management data (U.M.), and online obituary data were compared to NDI.Results: Among 40,692 patients, 25,761 (63.3%) had a death date using NDI; the composite algorithm had a sensitivity of 88.9% (95% CI = 88.5%, 89.3%), specificity was 89.1% (95% CI = 88.6%, 89.6%). At the same time, positive predictive value (PPV) was 93.4% (95% CI = 93.1%, 93.7%), negative predictive value (NPV) was 82.3% (95% CI = 81.7%, 82.9%), and when comparing each individual source, each had a high PPV but limited sensitivity.Conclusion: The composite algorithm was demonstrated to be a sensitive and precise measure of mortality, while individual database sources were accurate but had limited sensitivity.Plain Language Summary: What is known on this topic:The National Death Index (NDI) is the gold standard for ascertaining death in the US, with several limitations, such as time lag and population restrictions.What this study adds:A composite mortality algorithm of several sources of death was shown to be a sensitive and precise in death ascertainment compared to the NDI.Individual mortality sources, such as the Social Security Death Master File and online obituaries, had limited sensitivity on their own compared to the NDI.Keywords: mortality, validation, National Death Index, real word evidence, obituary, claimshttps://www.dovepress.com/validation-of-mortality-data-sources-compared-to-the-national-death-in-peer-reviewed-fulltext-article-PORmortalityvalidationnational death indexreal word evidenceobituaryclaims
spellingShingle Jamal-Allial A
Sponholtz T
Vojjala SK
Paullin M
Papazian A
Eshete B
Mahmoudpour SH
Verpillat P
Beachler DC
Validation of Mortality Data Sources Compared to the National Death Index in the Healthcare Integrated Research Database
Pragmatic and Observational Research
mortality
validation
national death index
real word evidence
obituary
claims
title Validation of Mortality Data Sources Compared to the National Death Index in the Healthcare Integrated Research Database
title_full Validation of Mortality Data Sources Compared to the National Death Index in the Healthcare Integrated Research Database
title_fullStr Validation of Mortality Data Sources Compared to the National Death Index in the Healthcare Integrated Research Database
title_full_unstemmed Validation of Mortality Data Sources Compared to the National Death Index in the Healthcare Integrated Research Database
title_short Validation of Mortality Data Sources Compared to the National Death Index in the Healthcare Integrated Research Database
title_sort validation of mortality data sources compared to the national death index in the healthcare integrated research database
topic mortality
validation
national death index
real word evidence
obituary
claims
url https://www.dovepress.com/validation-of-mortality-data-sources-compared-to-the-national-death-in-peer-reviewed-fulltext-article-POR
work_keys_str_mv AT jamalalliala validationofmortalitydatasourcescomparedtothenationaldeathindexinthehealthcareintegratedresearchdatabase
AT sponholtzt validationofmortalitydatasourcescomparedtothenationaldeathindexinthehealthcareintegratedresearchdatabase
AT vojjalask validationofmortalitydatasourcescomparedtothenationaldeathindexinthehealthcareintegratedresearchdatabase
AT paullinm validationofmortalitydatasourcescomparedtothenationaldeathindexinthehealthcareintegratedresearchdatabase
AT papaziana validationofmortalitydatasourcescomparedtothenationaldeathindexinthehealthcareintegratedresearchdatabase
AT esheteb validationofmortalitydatasourcescomparedtothenationaldeathindexinthehealthcareintegratedresearchdatabase
AT mahmoudpoursh validationofmortalitydatasourcescomparedtothenationaldeathindexinthehealthcareintegratedresearchdatabase
AT verpillatp validationofmortalitydatasourcescomparedtothenationaldeathindexinthehealthcareintegratedresearchdatabase
AT beachlerdc validationofmortalitydatasourcescomparedtothenationaldeathindexinthehealthcareintegratedresearchdatabase